No one knows for sure. But one thing is clear. The cracks in its foundation are widening. This 9-year Bull has been the second longest Bull Market of all time. And like the first – the 10-year “Dot.com” Bull of the 1990’s – this Bull has no real reason to exist. Let me explain.
The stock markets typically move on one thing, and one thing only – earnings. That just makes sense. When you buy stocks, you are buying a part ownership in that company – a very small part, to be sure, but you do become a part owner, or a shareholder.
Now let’s bring this closer to home. If you were going to buy a Dairy Queen business, and two were available to purchase, which would you choose? Dairy Queen #1 brings in a good monthly income, but it has a lot of debt. It is cheaper than Dairy Queen #2. Dairy Queen #2 brings in just as much income as #1, but it has no debt – and, not surprisingly, its price is higher than #1.
Of course, you would buy #2. You want income (earnings), but you don’t want those earning to be gobbled up by payments on the debt. It’s the same with stocks. Big institutional buyers, who buy most of the stock, want companies that are making money, and they are willing to pay more for the shares of those companies. They usually look at the analysts’ projections of earning one, three, and five years in the future.
Trending: Trump Must Draw a Red Line in the Sand
Most of the Dot.com stocks that pushed the market up every year for ten years had virtually no earnings. The ones that did had very little income. So if you couldn’t measure the value of these companies, what metric could you use? Analysts invented “eyeballs” as a metric. They counted the number of people who viewed websites on the assumption that the sites that had the most visitors would prosper and make investors rich. That assumption was wrong.
In 2000 Wired published the Wired 40 – 40 Dot.com companies that they said promised: “A future of unlimited growth.” Most of those companies are bankrupt today, and no one remembers their names. If you had invested $10,000 and divided it venly among the 40 stocks, you would be $3,129.71 poorer today. A few of them – most notably Yahoo and Cisco – survived and are thriving today.
Ironically, Craig Winn, CEO of a company named Value America, said, “No eCommerce company has ever made a profit. Certainly, we will, and the analysts have us making a profit in 2001.” He made that statement in early 2000. In August 2000 he filed for bankruptcy.
On March 10, 2000, the NASDAQ index, driven by the Dot.com boom peaked at 5,048.62. It took exactly fifteen years (March 2, 2015) before it hit 5,000 again.
So eyeballs didn’t work well as a replacement for what has always worked – earnings. If you had invested in tech stocks in 1990 and held them following the crash in March 2000, you would have lost every penny you had made over ten years in the next two and a half years.
Well, what is driving the current Bull? It’s a combination of slight of hand and what Fed Chief Alan Greenspan once called “irrational exuberance.” The trickery portion is major stock companies buying back their own stocks. Interest in buying stocks by both small investors and professionals has been waning. If someone doesn’t buy the stocks when people want to sell, the market will drop. So the companies buy the shares (just like governments have done in the past to prop up their stock markets). I’ll explain this in more detail in a Webinar I will be teaching tonight.
Today’s version of “irrational exuberance” is being called the “Trump Bump.” Much of the move in the markets since the 2016 election has been due to emotional buying by investors who believe that President Trump’s policies will magically cause the stock market to go up. Since they believe this, they buy stocks. Since buying increases, stock prices rise. This becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Keeping in mind that I fully support President Trump and his policy goals, let’s examine the reasons people believe (incorrectly) that his policies will continue to drive the market higher and higher.
- Most Americans believe that the stock market reflects the health of the economy. While sometimes the stock market goes up as the economy advances, they are many more times when it does not. And there have been dozens of times when the stock market went up while the economy was very weak.
- Stock investors believe that because Trump is a businessman, the stock market will continue to rise. While that perception has certainly been true in the short run, emotion and beliefs can only prop the stock market up for so long. At some point, the average investor will realize that this market is not supported by enough earnings to justify its high prices, and they will exit. Many of the biggest investors have already done so.
- The biggest mistake investors have made is believing that Trump’s political decisions will cause the markets to continue to rise. This goes back to the first incorrect belief that a good economy equals a good stock market.
There are many other reliable indicators that the markets will suffer at least a 10% to 20% normal correction, and possibly a crash of 30% or more in the near future. On the Webinar tonight (Monday, Oct. 23 at 8:00 PM EST) we will discuss why five of the top professional investors believe a crash is likely sooner rather than later.
If you’d like to join us, register at https://register.gotowebinar.com/register/2241880398931200771
You can listen on your computer’s speakers, or you can call (646)307-1721, code 785-346-153#. When the audio pin is requested, just hit # again. This way you can watch the slides on your computer and hear the audio on your phone. Or, if you’re not near your computer, you can listen only.
I hope you can join us for this free Webinar. It may help you save your retirement fund.
This article was originally posted at www.ConservativeTruth.org
PLEASE LIKE US AT www.Facebook.com/DrTomTV
The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author and are not not necessarily either shared or endorsed by iPatriot.com.